Papa Leo's Awards
- 2004 Taste of Niagara Best Pizza
- 2005 Taste of Niagara Best Chicken Fingers
- 2006 Taste of Niagara Committees Choice and Best Specialty Pizza
- 2008 Buffalo Pizza Fest Best Buffalo Chicken Pizza and Best BBQ Pizza
- 2009 Buffalo Pizza Bash Best Steak Pizza and Best Buffalo Chicken Pizza
- 2009 Lockport Business Association Business of the Year
- 2010 Niagara USA Chamber of Commerce Business of the Year
